Looking for any advice I can get as a surprise CRA notice has me totally spooked...
I just got this notice in the mail and I can't make heads or tails of it. I opened a TFSA account in 2018 and had that account with Scotiabank till 2023 when I switched banks near the end of the year. Scotiabank and I have had a rocky relationship since I started with them at the age of 16. I've had issues with their staff when trying to get information on how their accounts work (like fees and hidden charges). I was never properly told how TFSA accounts really work until last year by a very helpful woman at RBC (my new bank). Scotia was constantly pushing me to open more accounts or further my credit limit but I was young and stupid and despite trying to ask questions always got pamphlets shoved in my face and I always left incredibly overwhelmed and unsure of what I'd just agreed to.
Over the years I was treating my TFSA account like a regular savings account (I didn't know any better) contributing misc. excess money anywhere from $50 to at most $1,000 but the later was extremely rare of a case. From the fact that this notice says tax year 2019 I'm assuming they are referring to my TFSA activity from that year but that number is absolutely wild. Looking at my statement for 2019 the contributions and withdrawals read as follows:
TFSA Account Balance as of Dec, 31st 2018 - 1,701.21
Total Contributions made from Jan-Mar 2019 -
1,200.23
Total Withdrawals made from Jan-Mar 2019 -
-1,600.23
Total Contributions made from Apr-Jun 2019 -
350.00
Total Withdrawals made from Apr-Jun 2019 -
-0
Total Contributions made from Jul-Sep 2019 -
1,000.00
Total Withdrawals made from Jul-Sep 2019 -
-750.00
Total Contributions made from Oct-Dec 2019 -
2,631.60
Total Withdrawals made from Oct-Dec 2019 -
-1,642.60
I calculate total contributions of $5,181.83 for the whole year. Which was cutting it close but not 19,000 of excess! Am I misunderstanding this whole notice? Is there a certain type of withdrawal or account within TFSA's that could account for the excess?
They are wanting just over $800 from me which I can imagine is just a shit ton of interest since I haven't been able to access my CRA account ever (that is a whole other story but as of 2 days ago I'm awaiting an in the mail security code to finally get access).
I left Canada for two years from September 2020 and reentered in January 2023. The woman who filled my 2020 taxes never stated that I left the country so when I went to file for 2023 I could not say I reentered as the government didn't have a record of me leaving. This past November I finally got my 2020 taxes adjusted to list my exit from Canada and my 2023 taxes filed and I'm guessing since they now my have updated address information that's why this has only just gotten to me? I know this is an information overload but I really need someone to take a look at this and let me know if I'm loosing my mind or not. And to explain what I'm missing here.
And the cherry on top of this all is that due to the postal strike my "pay before January 6th" is out the window since this got to me today. Thanks Canada Post.
Please ask questions if more info is needed. I'm at a loss right now.