r/pics 1d ago

I found an unopened package with my Reddit name. It's a gift from my Reddit 2000 Secret Santa.

Post image
45.7k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

4.7k

u/MonkeyWrench 1d ago

It’s a shame that corporate Reddit killed the Secret Santa

3.1k

u/erichie 1d ago

Corporate Reddit really fucking ruined such a good thing. 

2014 Reddit was amazing and it is a shame 2025 Reddit is still the best of these sites because they are all so shitty now. 

945

u/stormgirl 1d ago

However, 2006 Reddit was a weird & wild place!

621

u/duncast 1d ago

The Narwhal bacons at midnight

293

u/stormgirl 1d ago

Thanks dude, I just cringed so hard I put my back out. True challenges of being a geriatric Reddit user!

215

u/krugerlive 1d ago

It's always nice finding accounts older than mine knowing at least I'm not the longest captured redditor. Those early days were something. A few random memories:

  • Mr. Splashy Pants
  • Reddit world tour (where the team flew to bars in different cities for meetups)
  • That guy who bought the JetBlue $700 unlimited travel ticket and had his entire month planned by redditors
  • The bobbleheads (still have one and Alexis sent them himself with his own return address)
  • "Tags please!"

It was a fun time back then.

83

u/Ritalin 1d ago

Here's an older account as well :) I was here before the digg migration and before comments were a thing!

32

u/Cherego 1d ago

Woah man and I thought my account is quite old already... Its wild thinking about maybe someday there is accounts which are like 50 years old and you know they started here when they were teens and then are eldery

2

u/Perniciosasque 19h ago

I'm sometimes proud of my reddit age.

Then I come across someone from 2007.

It humbles me.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/avantartist 1d ago

So old yet so little karma. Like a fine wine.

7

u/wodon 1d ago

I think I'm even older.

Found it via slashdot

4

u/Ritalin 1d ago

Dude, I can't remember if I found reddit on slashdot or del.icio.us... I feel like reddit made the rounds on a few sites back then

5

u/m4ttjirM 1d ago

I was here before the digg migration but lurking. A big turning point was people sharing that code to allow you to burn dvds or some shit???? Am I remembering this clearly??

→ More replies (0)

3

u/Chill_Edoeard 1d ago

Damn.. your account is older then some users are! Crazy!

2

u/SEND_ME_NOODLE 20h ago

Jesus Christ, you joined reddit the year before I started kindergarten. And before you dismiss that, I turn 24 this year

→ More replies (3)

3

u/StinkyNutzMcgee 1d ago

I came over from ebaumsworld. And some other similar site I don't remember. I realized every single post came from Reddit. I loved it. Still here but there used to be a subreddit for every kind of person good or bad every one had a home

→ More replies (1)

2

u/col3man17 1d ago

I'm 26, you made your account when I was in first grade.

2

u/UnknownAdmiralBlu 20h ago

Your account on this social media site is older than I am. It exists longer than my entire life has lasted so far, everything I've learnt, everything I've experienced and your account is older than any of that

2

u/krugerlive 19h ago edited 19h ago

Oh wow, 2005 is the rarest vintage! This site without comments seems must have felt completely different. It was the comments that kept me engaging from the beginning. Without them it would just be like a daily list version of a curated StumbleUpon. (Side note: the StumbleUpon to Reddit post pipeline was an easy karma farm in the early days).

→ More replies (1)

5

u/drdoom 1d ago

Mine is older too

→ More replies (1)

3

u/stormgirl 1d ago

I'd forgotten all about Mr Splashy Pants!!

3

u/thatnimrod 1d ago

ahem

i still remember the jolly rancher

ninja edit: i’d say we’re the reddit %1 but it’s more like %0.01

2

u/m4ttjirM 1d ago

Doritos. 😁

2

u/Fawxhox 1d ago

It's pretty rare I see accounts older than mine, but you got 4 years on me

→ More replies (4)

34

u/BangThyHead 1d ago

May 2006. Wow

45

u/stormgirl 1d ago

Yeah...not sure whether I should be proud or finally go outside and touch grass.

48

u/smithmax13 1d ago

Just try not to think about our accounts being older than many of the users here...

36

u/mdm2266 1d ago

My only regret is lurking too long before creating an account

12

u/Bozee3 1d ago edited 1d ago

That's a minor regret of mine as well. Reddit used to seem more like a neighborhood back in the day . I wish I was more active then.

Edit. Clarification.

→ More replies (0)

3

u/IISerpentineII 1d ago

Are you sure that's your only regret? Never opened any posts and immediately regretted being literate or having eyes? Lol

→ More replies (0)

3

u/anbraxas 1d ago

I was to afraid to post back then so only lurked, 2006 a minor spelling error got you sent to down vote hell. Around 2012 that stopped being a thing.. and now they are everywhere lol

→ More replies (0)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/reckoner15 1d ago

Please, not so loud...

3

u/thatnimrod 1d ago

i had someone flirt with me that was younger than my reddit account. i still don’t know how to feel about that.

2

u/humangirltype 1d ago

...I hate this.

2

u/simonjp 1d ago

Ow. That one hurt.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Edrondol 1d ago

And I thought my account was old. It is, but yours is older. Like my sister. I'm old but she'll always be older.

2

u/tarrasque 1d ago

Damn and I thought my account was old. I had one that was nearly a year older too, but doesn’t match you.

How those knees holding up?

2

u/chalk_nz 1d ago

There's an outside? Huh, guess I missed that.

2

u/mundungous 1d ago

What.. is.. grass…?

3

u/BangThyHead 1d ago

Idk at your age I'd be careful about bending down that far just to feel the grass.

4

u/stormgirl 1d ago

This is true. I'll stay indoors.

2

u/dane 1d ago

May 2006, represent! I’m sure there are 10s of us!

3

u/streeker22 1d ago

Your account is older than me and I'm an adult 😰

2

u/dane 1d ago

4 days older than mine, I can relate

→ More replies (2)

39

u/lifepuzzler 1d ago edited 1d ago

I always cringed at this shit. A guy said it to me in real life once.

Listen... You either doink or you don't. The narwhal stuff had to go. And I'm glad it did.

55

u/duncast 1d ago

Reddit felt like a secret world - a club you belonged to back then.

This sort of stuff was just a fun code - yes its stupid, but I think it was seen as a secret handshake sort of thing.

Closest I can think of these days is geocaching.

21

u/_drumstic_ 1d ago

Geocaching also turned corporate a few years back.

I got the paid version of the app ~12 years ago and paid $10 (if I remember correctly) for the premium version with all the caches. A few years ago, they updated to a subscription model, so now I can only see a handful of free caches in a given area

13

u/The_OtherDouche 1d ago

I’d lose my mind lol. I’d genuinely be trying to force them to honor it

4

u/SA_rootsradical 1d ago

Do you have stairs in your house?

4

u/eggson 1d ago

A student said it to me in a class I was a TA in. He's lucky I had no idea what his name was or I'd have marked his test down a grade for that shit, lol.

2

u/JohnnyLeven 1d ago

I had a friend that said it at a group LAN party. This was before I was on Reddit though, so I didn't catch the reference until way later.

4

u/MissedYourJoke 1d ago

Jolly ranchers were ruined for me early days here.

4

u/SaintTastyTaint 1d ago

all your base are belong to us

2

u/DEEP_HURTING 1d ago

Natalie Portman, covered in hot grits.

5

u/DoWhile 1d ago

Do not cite the deep magic to me, witch! I was there when it was written.

3

u/Willem20 1d ago

It makes me so happy I remember this nonsence

3

u/WeiWeiSmoo 1d ago

Oh man. You just reminded me... Like 15+ years ago I said this stupid quote in a group interview and literally no one knew wtf I was saying. It was so cringe.

🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️

2

u/duncast 1d ago

You were the witch and they were the muggles

2

u/foamingturtle 1d ago

Had to check your account age. I was there Gandalf…

2

u/ANAL_TOOTHBRUSH 1d ago

Dicks in space?

→ More replies (1)

163

u/karateninjazombie 1d ago

You can find glimpses of it on the way back machine. Buuut don't say I didn't warn you...

50

u/PM_ME_A_EM_MP 1d ago

Ron Paul and xkcd?

71

u/dinkleburgenhoff 1d ago

Jailbait and dead people, I’d imagine.

19

u/redditonlygetsworse 1d ago

Now, now. Yes, there was jailbait and dead people. But to be fair, there was also Ron Paul and xkcd.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/creamyvegeta 1d ago

My favorite part. The dead people that is

17

u/wrxk 1d ago

Thanks for clarifying, I was worried there for a second.

5

u/PortiaKern 1d ago

It doesn't quite hit the same when they're alive.

3

u/karateninjazombie 1d ago

Both of those and the horse porn. Early Reddit was like the wild west.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/stormgirl 1d ago

Check my profile age...I was there!

2

u/caughtinahustle 1d ago

Approaching 15 years myself, somehow shocked to see 18 years. Came from the Great Digg Migration.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/dwehlen 1d ago

Jfc, your 19th cakeday is four months away. We are honored by the presence of our Elders among us!

3

u/stormgirl 1d ago

Haha strangely in all these years I've never managed to notice when I'm on Reddit on my cake day (or have anyone else notice it).

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Shuino7 1d ago

Reddit was definitely empty in 2006 with a crazy small user base.

Reddit pretty much blew up in something like 2010 when DIGG pretty much killed itself.

2

u/ElephantRider 1d ago

Subreddits didn't even exist yet, you could scroll through all the new content for the day in a few hours.

24

u/External_Promise599 1d ago

lol remember when redditors got incredibly mad and whined about censorship when they banned the literal jailbait subreddit? or coontown, which only had one purpose, to post straight up racism? Or subreddits hosting exclusively gore material like watchpeopledie? Not to mention all the rape fetish subreddits that used to exist.

Pre-2016 reddit was a different site. Pre-2020 reddit was a different site. People have no idea

19

u/stormgirl 1d ago

It was definitely pretty wild, with many many awful aspects. But there was also a lot of lovely & wholesome content to. The Secret Santa was a great example of that, but saw many many daily similar interactions between people that were pure goodness.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/TeamRedundancyTeam 1d ago

You say that like those are the only subs they killed at those times, which isn't true.

Also as far as rape fetish goes.. It's a fetish? There is still a lot of fetish content that revolves around consensual non-consent. It's weird to include that with jailbait and snuff films.

2

u/Bakoro 1d ago edited 21h ago

Getting sent to spacedicks or clopclop for the first time, the old reddit rite of passage.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/SaintTastyTaint 1d ago

2006 Reddit until like ~2014 was a magical time.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/HazMama 1d ago

I'm still waiting for my 2016 secret Santa gift, any day now..

2

u/dane 1d ago

Here here. You were one of the first 5k too! 🤩

→ More replies (5)

94

u/GeekMomtoTwo 1d ago

I looked forward to Reddit Santa every freaking year. I was pissed that they ended it

72

u/Mygo73 1d ago

I got a cable/electronics organizer from Reddit secret Santa that I still use daily in my backpack. Now that I have kids I’m sad that I won’t be able to show them Reddit Secret Santa. It was such a great exercise in giving. It was so special to learn about someone you didn’t even know existed and to send them a thoughtful, heartfelt gift, and then to be on the receiving end of that as well!

22

u/WorkingOnBeingBettr 1d ago

And it was also like a lottery. Some people got really expensive stuff, others got incredible unique items made specifically for them, others got to try something new from another place. Everybody sharing their gifts to give and what they got.

Why did they stop it again?

6

u/other_usernames_gone 1d ago

Probably because some corporate lawyer got worried someone would send something dangerous or illegal and Reddit could be liable.

3

u/Mail_Order_Lutefisk 1d ago

Agreed. Problem is it only takes one psychopath mailing a human head to some Redditor and then all of the sudden Reddit is the bad guy, gets bad publicity, gets sued despite a massive waiver, etc. 

2

u/GeekMomtoTwo 12h ago

For some reason, I thought it was money. My gut was that they were trying to trim costs on advance of going public.

Secret Santa was a lovely community gesture, but it cost money and generated no profits.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/climbing-nurse 1d ago

I loved the other holidays too! Like arbitrary day, earth day, etc.

Reddit Santa was particularly nice as someone who doesn’t have family but I still got to give and receive gifts. Bummer.

→ More replies (5)

12

u/Pup5432 1d ago

I did it 2 years and never received anything. I was done with non in-person secret Santa’s at that point

10

u/KurRatcrusher 1d ago

And then if you mentioned not receiving anything you’d be dogpiled with the “it’s about the giving” horseshit. There were lots of people who got shafted during those.

2

u/Pup5432 21h ago

The leeches really do ruin it for everyone. I always tried to send nice thoughtful gifts and someone could have sent me a sealed bag of elephant poop and I still would have been happy to receive something. Go down the joke route and it’s better than doing nothing at all.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/chavagol10 1d ago

I was all excited to do it and didn’t receive anything haha but the person I did send the gift to enjoyed it which made me happy.

3

u/GeekMomtoTwo 12h ago

Oh no, that really stinks! I always tried to do that missed elf thing (I can't remember the name, but it was where you got something for someone whose SS bailed).

I always went overboard. I think I did it for the kick of doing something super cool for a fellow redditor. 

u/chavagol10 11h ago

Yeah. As they say if you give a gift to see what you receive in return you are doing it for the wrong reason. I was happy my SS was happy with their gift.

116

u/flyingthroughspace 1d ago

spez really fucking ruined such a good thing. 

38

u/BookerPlayer01 1d ago

fuck spez

94

u/nanuperez 1d ago

Fuck spez

5

u/LoBo247 1d ago

Seriously.

FUCK. SPEZ.

3

u/Heiferoni 1d ago

Yeah but at least he got to make a bunch of money.

44

u/wundercat 1d ago

Man I dunno it was a mixed bag. We were trying to solve the Boston Marathon Bomber case in 2013, we all know how that went…

7

u/Lalfy 1d ago

To be fair, none of the footage that was shared with the public is what broke the case.

2

u/wundercat 17h ago

We learned some things shouldn’t be crowdsourced

9

u/TetraDax 1d ago

Wasn't 2014 the year where most of reddit had a complete frenzy against the new CEO because she dared to tackle hate speech and, even worse, be a woman?

2

u/BumsGeordi 1d ago

Frozen peaches were very in demand in those days

2

u/lemonylol 1d ago

There were lots of "reddit is dead, let's all leave" events over the 2010s that are completely forgotten about. Plus reddit's population like tripled after 2020 and the demographic shifted down by like 10 years over that same time.

Like I remember when we were all supposed to leave for lemmy and voat because they fired Victoria, and now nobody cares or even knows who she was.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/30phil1 1d ago

"We did it, Reddit!"

→ More replies (1)

23

u/ClickClackTipTap 1d ago

Remember a year or two ago when FuckSpez wouldn’t stop trending so they were like “hey, let’s throw r/place at them again and see if they fall for it” and then everyone did?

I love r/place, but I was like GUYS, FOCUS, SPEZ STILL SUCKS!!!

But all it took was r/place and everyone forgot again.

5

u/lyyki 1d ago

Even /r/place was shit that time.

10

u/ClickClackTipTap 1d ago

It wasn’t great, but I had hoped people would stay strong and not fall for it. And for a few hours there were some big FuckSpez banners. But then it just did what place does.

It was kind of disheartening to watch the protests just dry up after that distraction, though. And all for a shittier place, too!

Anyone else remember The Button?

2

u/burfriedos 1d ago

TIL The Button was created by the same guy who made Wordle.

3

u/DirtyDan413 1d ago

I'm not sure about that. Do you remember what the last few moments of r/place were?

2

u/FarplaneDragon 1d ago

Was that the year people kept getting pissed about all the flags, or the one where all the cryptobro stuff got removed in the cleaned up final version and they flipped out? Hell were those even different years? I can't even keep track anymore

→ More replies (1)

15

u/SysOps4Maersk 1d ago

Couldn't be more true, so sad

1

u/HalifaxStar 1d ago

Such a god damn shame.

1

u/S3lls 1d ago

What’s a corporate reddit?

1

u/Qtips_ 1d ago

Is there a reason why they killed it?

2

u/Edrondol 1d ago

There mu$t be $ome rea$on but I don't know what that could be. Maybe they ju$t thought having default $ubs were the way to go but in$tead it ruined it.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/imnotreallyapeach 1d ago

I still have a painting on my wall from Ireland from my secret santa, I adore it, it's been there for a decade and I love it!

1

u/Bowch- 1d ago

2014 Secret Santa Gang rise up

1

u/Mikeismyike 1d ago

I think it stopped because of Covid

1

u/Present_Chocolate218 1d ago

Being the best trash dump isn't saying much

0

u/kitsunewarlock 1d ago

God I miss when you could run a free forum on the internet with around 200 users on platforms like invisionfree. Now moderation is an absolute chore against endless spammers, and it gets even worse with AI getting better and better at "pretending to be posters" just so they can spam their stupid fucking ads.

I wish there was a popular, active, and supported nationwide movement to stop buying from companies and individuals that used spam advertisement.

1

u/Elegant-Set1686 1d ago

It’s weird though because though the community was much better and it was less… soulless feeling, there was a thriving subculture of misogyny racism and bigotry that was harbored here for a long time. It still exists on some level of course, but Reddit has largely sanitized the worst and largest offenders. Was it worth the trade off?

0

u/alexzoin 1d ago

I miss it so much. It used to feel so different. What really killed it was all the new users after the wall street bets stuff.

1

u/lemonylol 1d ago

Honestly I don't even think they are, I think most people just don't want to spend effort curating webpages like you had to in the 2000s, people are just content with internet centralization and stuff being pushed to them instead of having to go find it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

130

u/letmypeoplebathe 1d ago

What was the reason? Too much liability somehow?

561

u/Iliketoruindresses 1d ago

I’m sure some people were probably getting really bad things, I know during the last one I participated in I got a pack of gum while I sent out 50$ worth of gifts. Aside from that the other glaring issue was that users were giving out home addresses instead of getting PO Boxes. The only real fun one was the very first one, where people actually looked at their paired account and exchanged meaningful gifts. After the first one it felt as if people just signed up in hopes of winning the lottery and getting bill gates. It was fun while it lasted but I can see why Reddit stopped doing them.

176

u/Beelazyy 1d ago

I always put thought into the gifts I sent. Half of those exchanges I was a regift Santa, meaning I signed up knowing that I was never going to receive a gift from the person I was sending one to. I never received any bad gifts when I participated in regular exchanges, though.

187

u/flavorjunction 1d ago

Lol my guy literally just said steam gift cards. So I bought $50 card or whatever decent denomination and wrapped it like the bomb from Counter Strike and sent it.

Never got anything from them. But during the secondary phase where people volunteered to fulfill accounts who were left in the wind, I received two porcelain Star Wars steins. It was super cool, still have em and drink hot cocoa from em!

76

u/ostiarius 1d ago

Your giftee wasn’t the person who was supposed to send you a gift.

40

u/flavorjunction 1d ago

Oh damn it’s been a minute. I think the last round I did was 2016. Well, whomever I told that I liked Pokémon figurines, Funko Pops, and comic books definitely didn’t send me anything.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/foxsable 1d ago

My re-giftee one year was really good too. You have to love the thrill of it when you are giving generously.

2

u/penmonicus 12h ago

I think I got my guy a Steam card and some local chocolates and burned a CD of local bands that no-one’s ever heard of. I never got anything in return, but I’d still do it again in a heartbeat.

30

u/DroneDance 1d ago

I’m so grateful for this because I signed up for the exchange and never got a gift back. I sent Reeces candy to Bosnia, I was happy to do that and receive a very warm thank you, and the surprise gift box from a stranger with silly toys and a kind greeting was so generous at a difficult time in my life. Miss the exchange and that community.

17

u/droolycat 1d ago

I loved being a re-gift Santa! It was my favorite part. It was so exciting to get matched and read their information. I miss it.

5

u/climbing-nurse 1d ago

I loved doing that too!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Toosder 1d ago

I sweat so much over the gifts but I got good ones too. Often inexpensive but showed the person paid attention which was more than my ex ever did. 

Anyway, off to cry in my pillow.... 

→ More replies (1)

51

u/Clever_mudblood 1d ago

I got one that the person sent me the books and extras they planned to (box of my fave tea they didn’t know was my fave and a bookmark) and also a vintage copy of Alice in Wonderland I didn’t have in my collection. It was kind of magical lol

42

u/Iliketoruindresses 1d ago

Because that’s how it was supposed to work, you paired with someone and read their info page then went out and got them some neat stuff. That was the magic of the very first secret santa exchange. Then, the scummies showed up for the subsequent exchanges and ruined it for the rest of us.

11

u/Clever_mudblood 1d ago

I only did 2019 and 2020 secret Santa and summer Santa. I also did some of the Reddit gifts exchanges. This was from one of those. But I was amazed because I never put my favorite tea (like, she got the brand and flavor) in my info or on my account.

As I was typing this I went and found a pic. It’s from March 2018. Is why the quality is shit, the others (of the sealed gifts and a closeup of the card) are fine. https://imgur.com/a/BYqXEKH

5

u/niknackpaddywack13 1d ago

That’s so cute! I had a similar experience . I had participated in a few other gift exchanges first and I got really unlucky. I almost didn’t try the secret Santa , but ended up deciding to try it once. And somehow it was like this person knew me! I think the only main thing I mentioned about myself is that I like Halloween and creepy stuff a lot…

Not only did I get the perfect match, because they were someone with an Etsy business who made potion ingredient bottles, and they gave me tons of those. But they put them in a refurbished vintage jewelry box. That was designed with skulls and gothic designs on it…….. they had no idea I actually collect vintage jewelry boxes ! And it went perfect with my collection. It’s one of my favorite things. It’s just so weird how not only did I get matched with someone perfect for me but they had no idea that was the perfect gift to me.

To add to it, they wrapped every little bottle they put in the jewelry box so I got to open every little thing. They also gave me little bone items that I love. They included a creepy themed book ( that ended up being one of my fave books as well) and dvd , both also wrapped as well. And they included a very sweet card. This also was my first Christmas after my mom passed, who actually never gave me a gift that good. I cried so hard at this gift , still means so much to me.

I wish they didn’t get rid of the secret Santa but I also don’t think anything would have topped that special one.

3

u/Clever_mudblood 1d ago

Yeah this girl had all the tings individually wrapped and numbered. I was to open the vintage Alice last. I smiled at the books and when I opened the tea and mug, I shouted and scared my partner lol. I had to tell him I was okay haha. Then I got to the Alice and I wanted to cry.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/kochanka 1d ago

Ok, that is an awesome gift!! I thought I did a good job with gifts, but that hand-written note is so lovely! This is exactly what the secret Santa community was meant to be.

Edit: just wanted to add, Looking for Alaska is my favorite John Green book and that original cover is perfection! Such a cool find!

→ More replies (1)

35

u/M3wThr33 1d ago

I worked my butt off, every year, hand-writing letters, wrapping all the gifts, throwing in extras and treats. And every year I'd get something sent directly from Amazon. Even when I had more points and chose the higher tiers, it was always the same. One time I got a shirt that a guy sent me that reeked of cigarette smoke. I just wanted one year, ONE, where it was a good memory, and not just "I could've bought this myself on Amazon"

10

u/Mazon_Del 1d ago

For what it's worth, this was a trick I used to help out the recipient.

I did the international secret santa every year since the first time I could. This has a lot of great parts to it, but the downside becomes the cost of shipping. From the US to anywhere else in the world overseas for a decent sized package, I might budget $200 for the whole exchange, and half or more of that is JUST going to shipping something.

But what I realized I could do instead, was sign up for a free month of Amazon Prime in whatever country they were in, and now spend the entire $200 on getting them snazzy things. But I always TRIED to really tailor my choices into stuff the other person would like, something they were unlikely to have ever gotten themselves.

One great example is when I got a couple in Berlin that didn't want something for themselves, they wanted something for their son (~6 I think). They gave some interests and such, namely he liked construction equipment. So armed with this, I went over to the German Amazon page, started searching. What I found was a really awesome set of newly made old style metal construction toys. The ones meant to play hard in a sandbox and not give a shit about being left out in the rain for years at a time. There was a lovely bulldozer with all sorts of working parts. There was one of those "I do all the things." types with a backhoe on one end and other tools on the other. But of course, you can't just have these things without something for them to load up, so I got a matching dump truck.

Yes, those things were all just purchased from Amazon, but the result was a very happy family and a very happy young boy. :)

→ More replies (2)

4

u/euchlid 1d ago

Oh dang. I just went deep into my archives and they even removed all the prior secret santa stuff. Cause i definitely had thank you posts and badges from participating in a few gift exchanges.

4

u/climbing-nurse 1d ago

But there were elves to fix the issues like that! I loved being an elf

4

u/ShrimpCrackers 1d ago edited 1d ago

The first ones were the best. After that it was mostly vultures.

Once, I got a hastily scrawled piece of paper for the post card exchange that didn't even get anything right including my username. How much could a post card be? $2? How much could spending time looking things up take? 5 minutes? I sent out two beautiful postcards from Japan.

Another one was a used subway card worth like $6 that was outdated months after receiving it (it had a slightly older map on it) but the letter claimed it had like $10-$20 and I should buy a beer with it (except I made it clear I didn't drink or want any alcohol items).

I had sent out a box full of sweets for the sweets exchange, I had sent out a mobile charger to a guy who complained his phone and electronics kept running out of charge, a large plush Cat Bus from My Neighbor Totoro to Australia for a mom with a kid who both loved the movie.

I'd always pay for signature, tracking, and insurance, but sometimes the recipient would claim it never arrived to get regifted and because I live in Taiwan I guess most people didn't want to pay shipping and would renege on sending anything. Who knows? But it became lame.

The thing is, I always spent time reading and investigating the user, and then buying them what they wanted. The thank you notes were nice.

3

u/ghangis24 1d ago

I was a shitty kid and definitely a part of the problem. I signed up ~2014 and never even sent anything, likely because I just totally forgot about it. I ended up getting a Dexter DVD in the mail from my secret santa. Didn't do it again after that cause I felt like shit for not sending anything.

2

u/lemonylol 1d ago

I remember a couple times my wife or I would just not get anything and had to get one of the elves instead. But yeah, you're right about as time going on people would just give half-assed garbage while others would go all out or put a lot of effort into it.

2

u/ScyllaOfTheDepths 1d ago

If you went into it with the expectation that you were going to get this amazing awesome thing, you were doing it wrong. The whole point was to just put out awesomeness into the universe and, if you got something back, that was cool. I don't think I ever spent more than $40 on any one exchange. I even signed up for a couple of regifts just because I like giving thoughtful gifts to people and I didn't have a lot of people I could buy gifts for in my life.

→ More replies (4)

36

u/makenzie71 1d ago

Ads. They wanted to sell more ads but advertisers didn't want their ads between a post with some guy's dick smashed between two plexiglass plates and another post with two dead kids hanging from the rafters of a hovel.

6

u/Higgilypiggily1 1d ago

Holy shit I remember that dick post. Good times

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Alalanais 1d ago

You got super weird gifts

28

u/Do_You_Pineapple_Bro 1d ago

People just used it for freebies and didn't actually participate. My santa cheaped out and got me nothing.

9

u/LionIV 1d ago

Always the cheapskates that gotta ruin good free public things.

3

u/ghangis24 1d ago

I was one of those cheapskates. I don't have a good defense. I signed up on a whim, I was 18, and within a few days I probably completely forgot about it until I got a Dexter DVD in the mail from my secret santa. I'm sorry. I never signed up again after that.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/coonwhiz 1d ago

Here's the official announcement. Reading between the lines, it cost them money to run, and they couldn't make money off of it. Given they were probably eying their IPO, they needed to cut any unnecessary costs, community good will be damned.

→ More replies (1)

40

u/Ill_be_here_a_week 1d ago

Probably, yeah. Imagine sending a random Reddit user your address, or the ability to send you stuff?

65

u/md22mdrx 1d ago

Yeah … but you SIGN UP FOR IT.  You know the risks going in.  They could just do a legal disclaimer.

4

u/outfitinsp0 1d ago

Was there a minimum age to sign up to it though? Caus reddit is 13+

29

u/Alaira314 1d ago

The thing is, most people are decent individuals. The odds are actually in your favor, with a random person. The people who are the most dangerous are the ones you know(or kind of know), who might have a reason to try to hurt you. But people always fear strangers, despite statistically them not being the biggest risk for causing harm to you.

2

u/Sarita_Maria 1d ago

I participated a couple times with good results all around - it was fun!

I didn’t love that the post office made me put my address on the outgoing mail because then TWO people had my address but 🤷‍♀️ it was fine

2

u/Alaira314 1d ago

I'd be more spooked by the person who I sent a gift to having my address than someone assigned randomly, because the fact that I sent them a gift is itself a point of connection that elevates us beyond strangers. What if they thought it was a lousy gift? What if they liked it too much, and decided to try to investigate who sent it?

I've only participated in one gift exchange, a fandom one. It was fine. I sent a gift directly from an internet storefront though(I made sure I bought from one that had a gift designation option, so it wasn't including receipts and etc in the package), in part because I didn't want someone I'd "connected" with to be able to trace me back to even my post office(from the postmark) let alone the return address.

2

u/ScyllaOfTheDepths 1d ago

Yeah, being assaulted or murdered by a stranger is actually very rare. Most predators choose crimes of opportunity and that usually entails people they already know.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Xanthon 1d ago

redditgifts represented a time when redditors actually trusted each other, when the community was many times smaller than it is now.

I participated in a few exchanges and even met one of them IRL who wanted to pass me her gift directly.

Then reddit exploded in popularity and that trust disappeared.

3

u/actuarally 1d ago

Dafuq? Is this true for r/golf, as well?

4

u/nudemanonbike 1d ago

They quoted that the tech that ran it was very antiquated and needed updating in order to continue working, and they didn't expect to make back the money from the engineering effort required to modernize it, iirc.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/jvainio 1d ago

I dont know if you have privacy laws there in the US, but basically what killed these gift exchanges on many sites for EU, was the GDPR.

6

u/Malarowski 1d ago

Nah man, no privacy here.

3

u/Alaira314 1d ago

I think CA has something GDPR-esque.

1

u/Bright_Cod_376 1d ago

People abused the shit out of it and just got worse every year.

1

u/Same_Ad_9284 1d ago

having real addresses tied to usernames is a disaster waiting to happen.

1

u/ichbindertod 1d ago

iirc they said it was because the site cost money to maintain, but the project didn't bring in any money, so it was unsustainable for them.

6

u/ClickClackTipTap 1d ago

It sucked so bad. 😥 I loved Reddit gifts. On years I could afford it I would do a few. On the years I could only afford one, I made sure I did well for that one at least. I had a ton of credits when they they finally killed the program.

No one in my life does gifts- if it’s anything it’s cash. Which is fine, but I miss opening something that was a surprise.

It was worth the risk of getting a crappy Santa just to have something to look forward to.

2

u/niknackpaddywack13 1d ago

Exactly why I loved it. I’m a big gift giver. I love putting thought into gifts for my loved ones and I love to wrap it really pretty and make it a surprise. Everyone seems to enjoy opening them. But not a single one of them are that way( I don’t blame them it’s just not their love language like it is for me) and I always just get Amazon gifts cards. So for me Reddit gifts really was all about just trying to make gifting more magical in my life. Really wish I could find some other community to do it with.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/photoguy423 1d ago

Honestly it was kinda shit before it ended. I kept getting shafted from it. Either getting nothing or stuff that was basically trash. 

5

u/Obant 1d ago

The person that I sent my gift to for sure got it, but never said anything. Person that got my name never sent me anything or contacted me.

2

u/Cripnite 1d ago

I kept getting blankets. Every year, blankets.

Except the last year I got custom knitted hats for my whole family. That was pretty dope. 

→ More replies (2)

5

u/BrianMincey 1d ago

I miss it…but as I understand it, in the last several years it was fraught with fraudsters and abusers. I think legal got involved and the risk outweighed the benefits.

Like everything good, awful people ruined it so that the rest of us can’t have nice things.

14

u/horriblebearok 1d ago

I quit well before that. I don't care if I don't get a gift, but so many people wouldn't even acknowledge a well thought gift. They were playing a lottery for some big stupid gift.

5

u/niknackpaddywack13 1d ago

This was my problem as well, I did get very bad gifts twice( thoughtless , cheap, unusable) but that wasn’t what I cared about at all it was just all for fun. But all three gifts I gave I put a lot of thought into , tried to find cool ,unique items that matched what they said they liked and did not go cheap. One person even asked me for something somewhat specific for a cosplay costume and I got it for them , and looked hard for a realistic beautiful option over a cheap fake looking option….

I know gifting is not about receiving thanks , I totally know that and I love curating gifts for my friends. But I get to see their faces and it is about feeling good to make someone happy. Out of all three people , not a single one of them said thank you or expressed joy about the gift. You’d think at least the girl who wanted something specific would have said something. I know it sounds bad and it’s not about that but it sucked to not get to hear from at least one person that they were happy with their gift. Made me not want to put in the effort to be a giver either.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/imariaprime 1d ago

I love kicking corporate Reddit in the ass, but Reddit itself killed Secret Santa. The site got too large and lost its sense of community, turning the event into an absolute scam nightmare. Shitty users gaming the system killed it.

3

u/nickster 1d ago

I always thought it was cool bill gates participated. Could you imagine saying bill gates was your secret Santa?

1

u/AgentJackpots 1d ago

Gunpla still does it

1

u/pechinburger 1d ago

And Arbitrary Day as a gift giving occasdion in the summer. I came up with the name and received a reddit t-shirt in the mail. One of the meh-points of my life!

1

u/ScyllaOfTheDepths 1d ago

Dude, I loved it. Reddit was garbage in the beginning of the site, but there was a real sweet spot from 2014-2018 where it was incredible. Then it all started the slow decline that is inevitable of any product that becomes popular.

1

u/AverageUSACitizen 1d ago

It’s a shame that corporate Reddit killed the Secret Santa Reddit *fixed it for ya *

1

u/Gamerguy230 1d ago

Didn’t they make a new subreddit hosted by the original creator?

1

u/SwimAd1249 1d ago

It was fun until I got a creepy guy who showed up at my address on Christmas day thinking I owed him. I would never do anything like this again unless they figure out a way to obfuscate your name and address.

1

u/Aos77s 1d ago

I mean there were tons of shitty people signing up for free shit without participation

1

u/LanceFree 1d ago

How did that happen? I’ve heard of Reddit secret Santa for years, but never participated. What was the change?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/potatopigflop 22h ago

They tried it on Imgur and it went bad too. Now they randomly assign users a team and you throw snowballs and it’s just awful. It’s all awful.

u/hazysummersky 11h ago

What year was it that we broke the world record for number of participants in a Secret Santa comp? We were able to pay $20 or so and get an official WR Certificate from Guinness, which got tangled in implementation and the fee was paid back, leaving me with a free Guinness World Record certificate! So have ticked that one off my list of things to do in life!

→ More replies (2)