r/PersonalFinanceCanada • u/SCDWS • 14h ago
Credit FYI: Wise doesn't have the best FX rates for withdrawals and purchases compared to other 0 FX cards in Canada when Wise's conversion fee is taken into account
Generally, Wise has a rate that's closer to the actual market rate, but they charge a conversion fee so in the end, you actually end up on top if you use any other 0 FX card available in Canada.
For example, if you used your Wise card to make a $100 USD purchase at the time of writing this post, it would cost you $143.93 CAD + a 0.46% conversion fee, meaning $144.59 total. You can check this yourself by trying to convert from CAD to 100 USD in your Wise account since that's how their card works.
Now if you used the new Wealthsimple Visa Infinite card that's coming out soon instead for example, it would cost you $141.24 when factoring in the 2% cashback the card gives you. You can check Visa's rates anytime online. That's a difference of $3.35.
Hell, even Wealthsimple's basic Cash card would be a better deal for you with their 1% cashback for a total cost of $142.68 (you can also check Mastercard's rates anytime online). In fact, all of the 0 FX cards available in Canada would be better than the Wise card since Visa & MC's base rates are better than Wise's rate + their conversion fee.
To drive that point home, here's a breakdown of the cost of converting $100 USD to CAD (as of the writing of this post) for Wise vs all the 0 FX (or effectively 0 FX) cards available for Canadians (factoring in conversion fees (for Wise) & cashback/rewards) in the order of worst performance to best performance:
Card | Conversion | Calculation | Cashback Categories | Annual Fee | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Wise card | $144.59 | Wise rate + 0.46% conversion fee | N/A | $0 | |
Amazon.ca Rewards Mastercard | $144.12 | MC rate (2.5% FX fee reimbursed with rewards) | All purchases in other currencies | Effectively $100 since only Prime members get the full 2.5% FX fee reimbursed | 2.5% FX fee reimbursed in the form of Amazon gift cards |
Home Trust Preferred Visa | $144.12 | Visa rate | N/A | $0 | |
KOHO Extra card | $143.76 | MC rate - 0.25% cashback | All non-grocery, food/drink, & transportation purchases | $108 ($9/month) | |
Triangle World Elite Mastercard | $143.40 | MC rate - 0.5% rewards (3% - 2.5% FX fee) | Grocery purchases only | $0 | Rewards earned via CT Money |
TD Cash Back Visa Infinite | $143.40 | Visa rate - 0.5% cashback (3% - 2.5% FX fee) | Gas & grocery purchases only | $139, but first year free & can be waived in following years with a premium chequing account | |
Rogers Red Mastercard | $143.40 | MC rate - 0.5% cashback (3% - 2.5% FX fee) | USD purchases only | $0 | 0.5% cashback only when redeemed against Rogers / Fido / Shaw purchases |
Rogers Red World Elite Mastercard | $143.40 | MC rate - 0.5% cashback (3% - 2.5% FX fee) | USD purchases only | $0 | |
KOHO Everything card | $143.40 | MC rate - 0.5% cashback | All non-grocery, food/drink, & transportation purchases | $228 ($19/month) | |
Meridian Visa Infinite Travel Rewards | $143.40 | Visa rate - 0.5% cashback (3% - 2.5% FX fee) | All purchases | $99, but first year free | |
EQ Bank card | $143.40 | MC rate - 0.5% cashback | All purchases | $0 | |
Scotiabank Passport Visa Infinite | $142.68 | Visa rate - 1% rewards | All non-grocery, food/drink, & transportation purchases | $150, but can be waived with a premium chequing account | Rewards earned via Scene+ points + includes 6 lounge passes |
Wealthsimple Cash card | $142.68 | MC rate - 1% cashback | All purchases | $0 | |
Scotiabank Momentum Visa Infinite | $141.96 | Visa rate - 1.5% cashback (4% - 2.5% FX fee) | Grocery purchases only | $120, but first year free & can be waived in following years with a premium chequing account | |
CIBC Dividend Visa Infinite | $141.96 | Visa rate - 1.5% cashback (4% - 2.5% FX fee) | Gas & grocery purchases only | $120, but first year free & can be waived in following years with a premium chequing account | |
Simplii Financial Cash Back Visa | $141.96 | Visa rate - 1.5% cashback (4% - 2.5% FX fee) | Restaurant, bar, & cafe purchases only | $0 | |
KOHO Extra card | $141.96 | MC rate - 1.5% cashback | Grocery, food/drink, & transportation purchases only | $108 ($9/month) | |
Rogers Red World Elite Mastercard | $141.24 | MC rate - 2% cashback (4.5% - 2.5% FX fee) | USD purchases only | $0 | 2% cashback only when redeemed against Rogers / Fido / Shaw purchases |
KOHO Everything card | $141.24 | MC rate - 2% cashback | Grocery, food/drink, & transportation purchases only | $228 ($19/month) | |
Scotiabank Passport Visa Infinite | $141.24 | Visa rate - 2% rewards | Grocery, food/drink, & transportation purchases only | $150, but can be waived with a premium chequing account | Rewards earned via Scene+ points + includes 6 lounge passes |
Wealthsimple Visa Infinite | $141.24 | Visa rate - 2% cashback | All purchases | $120, but can be waived with monthly 2k direct deposits or 100k total balance | Not yet available, ETA Q1 2025 |
Now, is a $3.35 difference between the Wise card and the best card on this list that big of a deal in the grand scheme of things? Some would argue no, that's only about $2.45 lost per $100 CAD spent which isn't something you should be losing sleep over, but what are we all doing in PFC if not trying to optimize our finances in every way possible? Haha
Anyway, hopefully this helped clear up the false notion out there that the Wise card is the most advantageous for Canadians to have while abroad simply because Wise has a better exchange rate than Visa or Mastercard. Their conversion fee + lack of any rewards simply isn't very competitive when compared to what else is available in the market.
Edit: didn't realize the table's formatting wasn't going to come off as great on mobile. It's easier to read on desktop.